Belmont Park

Chart (and photo) of the week: 27-horse field at Belmont, August 1945

On August 7, 1945, the fourth race at the wartime Saratoga at Belmont meeting masqueraded as a cavalry charge when twenty-seven colts and geldings took to the starting gate for a 5 ½ furlong maiden event.

The race was won by Top Flight’s cousin Our Bully (Bull Lea), who scored by a half-length over Uncle Mac (Rhodes Scholar (FR)), with Count Fleet’s full brother Count Speed (Reigh Count) next back in third.

The New York Times, 08/08/1945

27-horse maiden race at Belmont Park (08/07/1945), won by Our Bully.
Photo available from historicimages.com (Part number: nes42227).

Chart of the Week: 22 horse maiden race at Belmont, July 1943

At the wartime Saratoga at Belmont meeting on July 31, 1943, the first race of the day was a 5 ½ furlong maiden for colts and geldings, comprised of a robust field of twenty-two.

Won by Dustman (Blenheim II) by a head over Ariel Game (Ariel), the field also included the Sickle colt Sickletoy, a half-brother to Bolingbroke (Equipose), Thataway (Polynesian), and Whiffenpoof (Bull Dog), among others. While moderately successful on the track, Sickletoy is mostly of note for ultimately siring two foals – one being the champion mare Sickle’s Image – prior to his premature death in 1950 (more on Sickletoy here).

Also of note, future Hall of Famer Stymie is listed among the scratches for the race.

CHART - 22 horse maiden SAR (NYT 1943.08.01)

The New York Times, 08/01/1943

Chart(s) of the week: the 1951 & 1967 Suburban Handicaps

Going off as the 15-1 sixth choice, the 4-year-old filly Busanda (War Admiral) defeated the 5-year-old Isolater (GB) horse Lone Eagle (himself at 96-1) by 1 ½ lengths to take the 65th edition of Suburban Handicap (10f) at Belmont Park

CHART - 1951 Suburban (NYT 1951.05.31)

The New York Times, 05/31/1951


With the Suburban temporarily moved to Aqueduct, Busanda’s 4-year-old son Buckpasser (Tom Fool) kept the race in the family when defeating the 4-year-old colt Ring Twice (Gallant Man) by a half-length to win the 1967 edition of the race.

CHART - 1967 Suburban H. (NYT 1967.07.05)

The New York Times, 07/05/1967


Beginning with Busanda in 1951, the La Troienne (FR) branch of Family 1-x has won eight Suburban Handicaps (Busanda-1951; Buffle-1966; Buckpasser-1967; True Knight-1974; Easy Goer-1990; Pleasant Tap-1992; Mineshaft-2003; Frost Giant-2008).

1917: The Coaching Club American Oaks, a new filly classic

CCAO ad (TB Record, Vol. 85 No. 3, 1917.01.20)

The Thoroughbred Record (Vol. 85, No. 3), 01/20/1917


“The Westchester Racing Association is issuing blanks for a new serial stake which will undoubtedly prove one of the classics of America. The race is for three-year-old mares. In 1917, it will be run at the spring meeting of the Westchester Racing Association as a handicap; $3,000 guaranteed cash value, 1 ⅛ miles; in 1918 at this Association as a handicap, $4,000 guaranteed cash value, one and one-quarter miles, and 1919 at the spring meeting as a condition race, guaranteed cash value $5,000, one mile and three furlongs, and this last race will be known as “The Coaching Club American Oaks.”

These races will all close with the Secretary of the Westchester Racing Association on February 5, 1917. The 1917 race being for then three-year-olds; the 1918 race for then two-year-olds, and the 1919 race for then yearlings. To these races the Coaching Club of America will add the historical old Singleton Cup, to become the property of the owner winning the race three times, not necessarily consecutively, and will also add to each race a silver trophy to become the property of the winning owner of that year.

The Singleton Cup is a trophy donated in 1820 by the South Carolina Jockey Club, to be raced for over its Washington Course at Charleston, South Carolina, “to be liable for challenge hereafter, and must be won by the same gentleman three consecutive years or remain unchallenged during that period, before his property in it is complete.” This race was at two mile heats, weight-for-age, and was won by Colonel Singleton’s “Sally Taylor,” which was bred by Col. Singleton, and was by his famous horse “Kosciusko,” which had as a four-year-old won this race at three mile heats in 1819.

Such races as the above for mares is a thing very much needed at the present time on the American turf, as the question of elimination for breeding purposes is a much vexed one, and this race will eventually be known as “The Oaks” and the owner of the winner can point to the victories of the matron in such races with the same pride that the Englishman does to the winner of their female classic –their Oaks.” (The Thoroughbred Record (Vol. 85, No. 1), 01/06/1917)


1917 (as the Coaching Club Handicap): Won by Wistful (she would also win it again in 1949)

CCAO 1917 chart (DRF 1917.06.17)

Daily Racing Form, 06/17/1917


1918 (as the Coaching Club Handicap): Won by Rose D’Or

CCAO 1918 chart (DRF 1918.06.16)

Daily Racing Form, 06/16/1918


1919 (as the Coaching Club American Oaks): Won by Polka Dot

CCAO 1919 chart (DRF 1919.06.08)

Daily Racing Form, 06/08/1919

 

The greatest three days in racing history: Belmont Park, July 4-6, 1975

The New York Times, 07/04/1975

Hauca, Perida & Thingumabob

Hauca – 1936 ch. f. Wise Counsellor – Fire Boat by Big Blaze
Breeder/Owner: Glen Riddle Farm (Samuel D. Riddle)
Trainer: G. Conway

Record: (5) 3-1-0 / $2,255
ETR at Suffolk Downs (06/21/1938): 5 furlongs in :58 ⅘

Owned and bred by Sam Riddle, Hauca was a daughter of champion Wise Counsellor and the first foal out of the Big Blaze mare Fire Boat. Fire Boat was unraced, having been bred to Wise Counsellor as a 2-year-old.


Thingumabob – 1936 b. c. Boojum – Refine by Ormondale
Breeder: C. V. Whitney
Owner: Manhasset Stable (Joan Whitney Payson and Mrs. Charles S. Payson)
Trainer: William Brennan

New York Times, 08/12/1938

Thingumabob following his win in the 1938 Arlington Futurity. Photo: The New York Times, 08/12/1938.

Record: (3) 2-0-0 / $31,810
1st: Arlington Futurity (6f,AP)

Bred by C. V. Whitney and owned by Mrs. C. S. Payson’s Manhasset Stable, Thingumabob was a son of the speedy Whitney-bred stallion Boojum. Boojum, by John P. Grier, was a precocious sort who counted the Hopeful Stakes among his three wins as a juvenile, and “whose blazing speed was too much for the strength of his legs. Boojum broke down after a fine 2 year old campaign and was retired to the Whitney stud.” (Chicago Daily Tribune, 07/28/1938)

Following retirement to the breeding shed, Boojum would sire thirty-two foals at stud, one of them being the bay colt out of the young Ormondale mare Refine, later named Thingumabob.

Among others, Refine would later produce the Mahmoud (FR) filly Miss Mood (1944), who is of current relevance as the 7th dam of champion and current leading 3-year-old American Pharoah (2012 b. c. by Pioneerof the Nile).


Perida – 1937 b. f. Chance Shot – Black Queen by Pompey
Owner/breeder: Joseph E. Widener
Trainer: P. Coyne

Record: (3) 2-0-0 / $4,950
1st: Fashion S. (4.5f,BEL)

Owned and bred by Joseph Widener, Perida was the second foal out of the young Pompey mare Black Queen, herself the only foal produced by the champion mare Black Maria prior to that mare’s premature death in 1932.

It was an ill-fated line, as Black Queen’s first foal, the Polymelian (GB) filly Black Polly (1936), would produce only two foals before her premature death in 1942. One of those foals was the classic winning champion Polynesian (1942 br. c. by Unbreakable).


Hauca, Perida, and Thingumabob did not share pedigree, owner, trainer, or competition, and aside from sky high expectations, at first glance may not seem to have much in common. However, all three are forever linked as a result of the circumstances of their respective demises.

Saratoga – the graveyard of favorites, indeed.

MAY 1938
Under the tutelage of trainer William Brennan, the 2-year-old Thingumabob had garnered notice for his speedy works at Belmont Park, including a four furlong work in :48. Entered in a 4 ½ furlong maiden race at Belmont on May 10, Thingumabob would cover the sloppy going in :54⅖, winning by six lengths under Eddie Arcaro. Future stakes horse T. M. Dorsett would finish seventh in the field of fourteen.

JUNE 1938
The 2-year-old Hauca would make her debut at Belmont Park on June 1 in the Graceful Purse (5f). Racing greenly, she would finish second to Sun Girl by 1 ½ lengths. Five days later at Aqueduct, she would win a maiden event on June 6 by four lengths in 1:00 ⅗.

Hauca’s third and final start for the month of June would come at Suffolk Downs, where in a winning effort on June 21 she would equal the track record for five furlongs, running the distance in :58 ⅘.

JULY 1938
After a lengthy break, Thingumabob was shipped to Arlington Park in late July in preparation for the Arlington Futurity (6f) on July 30. While at Arlington, his athleticism in the mornings caused the maiden winner’s bandwagon to continue to grow.

“That he will be the favorite was made evident yesterday morning when he turned in the most sensational trial of the Futurity training period on the Arlington Park Course. Apparently as much at home in this going as he is over a fast track, he splashed mud in all directions while he breezed a half mile in the spectacular muddy track time of 48 seconds. He had stepped the first quarter in :22 ⅖ and the three-eighths in 35 seconds.” (Chicago Daily Tribune, 07/29/1938)

Now at Saratoga, Hauca would win a 5 ½ furlong allowance on July 29 by four lengths, clocking a time of 1:07 in the muddy going.

Thingumabob, again under the guidance of Eddie Arcaro, would take the Arlington Futurity on July 30 by five lengths in 1:12. No Competition would finish second, with Hants third.

“Not once during the race did Arcaro use his whip. Soon after he passed the finish line he hit Thingumabob one crack with it just to keep the bay son of Boojum-Refine from pulling up too suddenly. Thingumabob not only scored one of the easiest victories in the history of the Futurity but many horseman acclaimed him as the best looking juvenile ever to win it.” (Chicago Daily Tribune, 07/31/1938)

Chicago Daily Tribune, 07/31/1938

Thingumabob winning the 1938 Arlington Futurity. Photo: Chicago Daily Tribune, 07/31/1938.

Thingumabob - 1938.07.30 A Futurity chart (NYT 1938.07.31)

The New York Times, 07/31/1938

AUGUST 1938: SARATOGA, THE SANFORD STAKES
Following his win in the Arlington Futurity, Thingumabob would make a quick turnaround for the Sanford Stakes (6f) at Saratoga on August 11. Rumors swirled about Thingumabob, with railbirds saying that not only had insurance on the promising juvenile had been upped from $10,000 to $50,000, but that the Paysons had turned down a $200,000 offer for the colt.

“Classed with El Chico and Ariel Toy as one of the nation’s foremost juveniles, Thingumabob broke well and was coming up fast on the inside when the field went into the far turn. Here Ariel Toy swerved over. Suddenly the favorite faltered and the leg snapped. Jockey Eddie Arcaro took him around the bend and dismounted. Examination showed the leg had broken clean just above the ankle and there was no hope of saving the colt.” (Chicago Daily Tribune, 08/12/1938)

Los Angeles Times, 08/12/1938

Ariel Toy would finish first by a length over Birch Rod. He was later disqualified “partly because of what happened on the back stretch, and partly because of Ariel Toy’s bearing out just at the finish. …He was handled by Eddie Arcaro, who stated after the accident that he was not bothered by Ariel Toy. This makes the disqualification the more mysterious. Wayne Wright, rider of Birch Rod, lodged no claim.

Thingumabob started a trifle slowly, well back of the flying Ariel Toy, and was rushed up along the rail by Arcaro in an effort to save ground. Arcaro then ran into what is known on the race track as “an open switch.” Hardy, rider of Ariel Toy, “closed the switch” by bearing over toward the fence. This forced Arcaro to take back. In snatching Thingumabob back out of full stride, when the colt was just getting up steam in earnest, he may have stepped in a hole.

It is a fact that Thingumabob did not break down until after Ariel Toy had gone completely over to the fence and begun to draw off. Whether or not Ariel Toy actually bumped Thingumabob is a matter for the patrol judge on duty at that point. He made no such statement that could be gained by the press.” (The New York Times, 08/12/1938)

New York Times, 08/13/1938

The next day, the Saratoga stewards rendered the following verdict placing blame solely on Ariel Toy’s jockey, Lee Hardy.

“The racing stewards at Saratoga, after a long and detailed investigation, today charged Lee Hardy, veteran jockey, with causing the accident which resulted in the destroying of Mrs. C. S. Payson’s highly regarded two-year-old Thingumabob, during the running of the Sanford Stakes yesterday.

As the result the 30-year-old Lexington, Ind., rider was suspended for the remainder of the meeting, which ends August 27, and an additional ten racing days and his case referred to the Jockey Club for further action.

On the report of the patrol judges stationed at the point of the accident, the stewards charged Hardy with deliberately crossing in front of Thingumabob and causing interference. Eddie Arcaro, up on Mrs. Payson’s colt, was forced to take up sharply, which is believed to have caused Thingumabob to break his leg.

In their ruling the stewards said an inspection revealed marks on the rail where the accident occurred. A subsequent examination of the body of the horse showed a shoe to have been pulled half off the left fore foot, a severely-grabbed left quarter and badly torn ligaments in the right fore leg.

Ariel Toy, Hardy’s mount, also was disqualified from first money for swerving in front of Trailer and Birch Rod, ridden by Raymond Workman and Wayne Wright, respectively, in the stretch run. Birch Rod, a rank outsider, was awarded the purse.” (The Washington Post, 08/13/1938)

AUGUST 1938: SARATOGA, THE SPINAWAY STAKES
On August 13, two days after the Sanford, Hauca would make her stakes debut in the Spinaway Stakes (6f). With three wins in four starts and a track record equaling effort to her name, she was instilled as the favorite for the race.

New York Times, 08/14/1938

“Thanksgiving won the historic Travers before 20,000 at Saratoga today as tragedy struck for the second time within three days. Samuel D. Riddle’s Hauca, favorite for the Spinaway, secondary feature, suffered a broken leg at the far turn, and had to be destroyed. The accident happened at almost the precise spot where Thingumabob suffered a broken leg on Thursday.

The stewards grounded [Jocky] Lee Hardy following the Thingumabob accident and this afternoon issued the following statement in the Hauca case: “Jocky [sic] Samuel Renick is suspended for the remainder of the meeting and ten additional racing days, effective Tuesday, Aug. 16, and his case referred to the jocky [sic] club. Renick’s suspension was the result of crossing over and causing Hauca to fall.” (Chicago Daily Tribune, 08/14/1938)

MAY 1939
Perida would debut at Belmont Park in a 4 ½ furlong maiden event on May 11, defeating Small World and future Reine-de-Course mare Thorn Apple by 1 ½ lengths in :53 ⅗.

Perida - Fashion (NYT 1939.05.14)

Wasting no time, she would return to the starting gate two days later in the Fashion Stakes (4.5f), winning her stakes debut by three lengths over Us in :52.

AUGUST 1939: SARATOGA, THE SPINAWAY STAKES
After an extended break following her win in the Fashion S., Perida’s next start would not come until the Spinaway Stakes (6f) at Saratoga on August 19. Despite having been away from the starting gate since mid-May, she would be named the favorite for the race.

Perida - Spinaway (NYT 1939.08.20)

“In the $10,000 Spinaway, Perida, the favorite, broke her leg and was destroyed. The accident occurred soon after the start of the six furlong sprint and near the spot where the fleet filly Hauca met her end in the same race last year. Other two year olds have come to grief at approximately the same spot, notably Thingumabob, another casualty of 1938.” (New York Times, 08/20/1939)